My vote is for Ipsy. I got a FULL SIZE nail polish, a makeup bag, a makeup brush, a deluxe size lotion perfect for travel, hairspray (which I have no use for, but still). In Birchbox the only thing I like is the nail polish. But it's so small. I'm also excited about the Balm primer. With primers a little goes a long way so ill get use out of it. But for the value, Ipsy hands down. And it's been this way for a while. Birchbox seems to be declining. It was good at first. And it's only $10 so I don't wanna cancel. But they're gonna have to do better.